Vietnam Interactive Portfolio, permanent archive

Military


YOU DIDN'T LOSE THE WAR. TRUST ME.

From Ky-Anh, on Thu, 13 Jun 1996 01:09:59 GMT (in response to: The Real Reason Why We Lost The War)

I can't help but refute the notion that the soldiers of the RVN or of the U.S. were the ones who lost the war. That certainly is not the way by which the ideals of those who fought and died is viewed from this perspective.

How do you lose something that was unwinnable? How do you lose something when the war was sustained by actions beyond your own controls? Case in points:

1. The RVN government was inept, corrupt, arrogant and insensitive
2. The RVN government never were in touch with the majority of
   the people nor was it able to serve the aspirations of social
   justice. This played into the hands of the communists.
3. The RVN government did not have:
   a. the courage nor conviction to stand up against U.S. 
      political agenda and allowed Vietnam to be toyed by
      the superpowers.
   b. the vision nor commitment to create a just society.

How do you help a power entity that does not help itself? How do you help one such entity when its actions and policies perpetuate social injustices and thus fueled the determination of the opposition? How do you stop a war that the major players (North and South Vietnam) did not care to stop? How do you cover all the bases of responsibilities by irresponsible Vietnamese leaderships?

It was not a military nor a political war. It was a battle of the wills. The will to resist will only gather strength when social justices exist and persist. One can exterminate thousans men and women of the enemy, but one can't abolish the will to fight by bullets. By justice, by social integration,by visionary and responsible leadership, yes! By bullets, no!

My salute and thanks to the veterans who have fought. In you, there are no futile losses, just awe-inspiring ideals within you and unconscienable sacrifices asked of you. These are the legacy you left behind for which I am eternally grateful. Sometimes, the aim of your best intentions is destroyed by the worst in others. Perhaps, for any future conflict, we will demand much more of our own sacrifices and those of others. Perhaps, before the next bullet is sent out of the muzzle, we will ask if and how it will solve anything.

Sincerely, KyAnh


Replies

  1. War CMSgt Ron McMasters (masters@imicom.or.jp), Sun, 30 Jun 1996 15:02:59 GMT
    1. Lam Son 719/ Dewey Canyon II Bill Baker (figarro@azstarnet.com), Sat, 20 Jul 1996 03:18:54 GMT
      1. Watching Lam Son 719 from FSB Sarge Ralph Carlson (rcarlson@apu.edu), Sat, 17 Aug 1996 01:21:50 GMT
        1. Re LamSon 719 JimL (jjlv@aol.com), Sat, 02 Aug 1997 22:42:19 GMT
      2. Untitled Not Important (), Sat, 05 Oct 1996 04:39:27 GMT
    2. War Jonathang (), Sat, 16 Nov 1996 17:22:02 GMT
      1. War (Jonathang's comment translated) Ky-Anh (kyanh@saigon.com), Sun, 17 Nov 1996 10:13:38 GMT
        1. War, I fail to understand Markus Drake (drake@sockom.helsinki.fi), Tue, 10 Dec 1996 13:20:11 GMT
          1. War (), Thu, 02 Apr 1998 17:44:19 GMT
        2. I agree if you are speaking about war in general. Randy Pham (randy_pham@micropolis.com), Thu, 17 Apr 1997 22:00:24 GMT
  2. Applause for Ky Anh Dinh Thi Phuc (), Sun, 03 Nov 1996 18:50:39 GMT
  3. The Greatest Reward is the receipt of Appreciation: THANK YOU Bruce Kelderhouse (BKinPHX@aol.com), Tue, 03 Dec 1996 23:29:33 GMT
  4. We could control what happend!!!! Terry Daniel (), Sat, 01 Feb 1997 02:56:28 GMT
  5. WE SHOULD'NT HAVE BEEN THERE 'SMFL' (), Tue, 11 Mar 1997 15:51:11 GMT
  6. Well Stated Keely (), Sun, 19 Oct 1997 19:36:20 GMT
  7. THANKS-I needed that Bill Hayden (), Mon, 02 Feb 1998 04:09:47 GMT

Vietnam Interactive Portfolio, permanent message archive. Copyright© E. Kenneth Hoffman, 1995-2005