From Tim LaTour, on Fri, 31 Jan 1997 05:13:03 GMT (in response to: Okay...but....????)
I certainly appreciate the terrible conditions you experienced in Vietnam as a grunt. But surely you recognize that for everyone in your position, there were at least 10 REMF's (rear echelon mf). Cooks, drivers, clerk-typists, mechanics, and even photographers. The vast majority of service men and women in Vietnam slept in hooches and showered every night. Some lived in fancy hotels in Saigon. I was a Huey pilot in a Cav unit in Pleiku and An Khe. We knocked heads pretty regularly w/ the NVA, and some of us were killed or wounded. We slept in bunks and had beer at night. Plush? No. But I didn't complain. Much of the war's legacy was related to drugs. My experience was that the REMF's had far greater access to and supplies of drugs. It is those people to which much of the war's bad "reputation" is owed. On the other hand, the grunts I knew were pretty drug-free in the field. In my division, we had the most trouble with base camp personnel who accounted for 99% of the discipline breakdown. So guys like you were in the very small minority. Your experiences and your environment were extremely unusual. A chronicle of the war will certainly include you among the true combatants, but you survived, at least. Many folks in base camps didn't. Rocket attacks on insecure base camps and smaller fire bases killed and maimed lots of noncombatants, including nurses, red cross volunteers, and construction contractors, people who had "safe" jobs. These people, plus the thousands of soldiers, airmen, sailors, and marines who didn't sleep under a poncho are the relatives and friends of most Americans. The larger story of the war -- the drugs, protests, loss of innocence, etc. -- will necessarily focus on the majority experience. One final point: I believe marines joined the service voluntarily as did I. But many, probably most, of the thousands killed in Vietnam were drafted. Poor, mainly black kids from inner cities got drafted and shipped, while their better positioned brethern skated. No need for one upmanship here. There's plenty of grief to go around.
Vietnam Interactive Portfolio, permanent message archive. Copyright© E. Kenneth Hoffman, 1995-2005